There is no specific age in New York at which a child gets to choose which parent to live with. A child’s preference is one factor a judge considers, and it carries more weight as the child grows older and more mature — a thoughtful teenager’s wishes are taken seriously — but the decision always remains with the court under the best-interests standard. The child’s views often reach the judge through the child’s own court-appointed attorney or through a private conversation with the judge called a Lincoln hearing.
Many parents believe that at a certain age — 12, 14, or 16 — a child can simply decide where to live. In New York, that is a myth. No statute sets an age at which a child’s choice controls. Instead, the child’s preference is one of many factors in the best-interests analysis, and the court decides.
That said, age and maturity matter. A young child’s stated preference is given relatively little weight, while an older, mature teenager’s reasoned wishes can be quite influential — though still not binding. Courts also look at why a child prefers one parent; a preference based on which home has fewer rules is treated differently from one rooted in genuine stability and connection.
New York has specific ways of hearing from children without putting them in the middle. The court appoints an Attorney for the Child to represent the child’s position. A judge may also hold a Lincoln hearing — a private, on-the-record conversation with the child, outside the presence of the parents — so the child can speak candidly without feeling they are testifying against a parent.
Because a child’s voice is handled carefully and never simply decides the case, parents navigating an older child’s preference often consult a New York custody attorney about how that preference will actually be weighed.
Looking for a custody lawyer in New York City?
Find a custody lawyer in NYCFrequently Asked Questions
Can a 12-year-old choose which parent to live with in New York?
No. There is no age at which a child's choice controls in New York. A 12-year-old's preference may be considered, but the court decides custody based on the child's best interests.
What is a Lincoln hearing?
It is a private, on-the-record conversation between the judge and the child, held without the parents present, so the child can share their views candidly. The judge uses it to inform — not dictate — the custody decision.
Does the child get their own lawyer in a New York custody case?
Often yes. In contested cases New York courts appoint an Attorney for the Child to represent the child's interests and voice their position to the court.